New Technology and Socialism
Sanjay Roy
A SOCIAL system cannot be changed simply by the will power of individuals, interest groups or a political party. A social system continues to remain relevant so long it can reproduce relations of production appropriate for the growth of productive forces. Productive forces include tools, machines, technology and most importantly human labour capable of working with the evolving means of production. Human civilisation essentially captures this continuous conflict between the growth of productive forces and the modification of or radical rupture of production relations. Production relations refer to relations between human beings in the act of production. The species being of humans manifests in the cooperation and coordination among themselves in the process of production. Nothing can be produced by solitary effort of isolated beings howsoever talented and efficient they may be.
Producing grains or motor cars, creating film or drawing pictures, writing poems or working in the factory, all involve engagement and realisation of mutual exchanges of ideas, skills and/or synchronisation of activities. Working with a laptop appears to be an individual activity, but while working one is situated in the worldwide flow of information and images flowing on the internet. The relation of production captures the modes of mutual effort vis-à-vis property relations—who owns the means of production, the employer class and on the other hand who are the non-owners and employees working for the employers. This division of class takes various forms, mutating from one to the other befitting for the growth of productive forces, most importantly evolving technology.
Progress of humanity is essentially the story of understanding and consciously changing the surroundings in favour of our own existence and wellbeing. By the same process, human beings and their mode of cooperation also undergo change. It is very much linked to creating technology of production that has made huge changes in human life. In the long march towards this progress, there may be stepping back here and there but the story is about reducing effort in the life process. Before the industrial revolution per capita income of the world used to double in every six thousand years, which came down to fifty years with the diffusion of technology triggered by the industrial revolution.
‘FREE TIME’ OR PROFIT
Technologies are meant to reduce direct human labour— be it in capitalism or in socialism. But this effect can produce two different outcomes. For instance, say 10 workers working for 10 hours a day produce 1,000 units of output. Now due to introduction of new technology if productivity doubles then there can be two outcomes if the same output needs to be produced: a) 5 workers working 10 hours a day will produce the same output; hence 5 workers can be laid off ; b) 10 workers work for 5 hours a day produce the same output. This creates no unemployment but increases ‘free time’ for workers who can use this time according to their choice. In other words, technology may not necessarily create unemployment rather it may also increase ‘free time’ of workers which is at their disposal.
The real question however is do the workers receive the same income for producing the same thing independent of the hours spent. If they are producing the same output, they should ideally receive the same wage for their work. Then only their free time will increase. Capitalism claims that workers receive wages according to their contribution, but actually it is not so. They receive wages according to the value of labour power equivalent to reproduce the capacity to work for ten hours in our example and not according to what they produce. This payment of wage according to the value of labour power enables employers to make them work for ten hours according to the contract. The workers however produce more value than the value of labour power and this is appropriated by the employer as surplus value. So, the payment according to the value of labour power allows capital to extract surplus value and the worker is forced to work because they have no other fall-back option, no assets or ownership of any means of production, hence they sell their labour power according to the conditions laid down by the employer.
The capitalist is also more inclined to intensify the work process without reducing time of work because the investment on existing technology must be realised as soon as possible before it becomes obsolete by new innovations. Therefore, in the course of history, even if technology has grown it has not led to a reduction in working hours. Instead, capitalism gives rise to binary outcomes: intensity of work for the existing workers increases while a share of the employed workforce is thrown out of jobs. But this outcome would drastically change if the land, machines, new technology and the production process is collectively owned by society. The purpose of technological change radically alters in that case. It reduces necessary work time and that is the beginning of real freedom. Marx’s idea of socialism begins with the quest towards the path of universal human freedom, and his initial critique of capitalism was that capitalism ensures freedom for few at the cost of wage slavery for the majority. But Marx also later talked about how individuality of the capitalist is also subject to systemic dynamics of capitalist competition. Emancipation from wage slavery therefore allows human beings to transcend the realm of necessity—when free time increases, human creativity is unleashed without being compelled by necessities of life, rather labour becomes the mode of realising life.
NEW TECHNOLOGY AND SOCIALISM
Physical capacities, particularly repetitive tasks, were codified and internalised into machines in the previous industrial revolutions. Now AI and machine learning internalise some of the mental processes into software and AI enabled machines. The purpose remains the same and that is to reduce direct human effort in productive activities. This also creates possibilities of releasing free time for more creative learning and thinking. However, the society driven by private property and profit motive faces serious problems with this new technology. First, the immense productive capacity created through technological innovations could not be fully utilised or absorbed due to the narrow base of demand in a highly unequal society. Second, a society driven by profit motive and competition creates excess capacities as this society has no mechanism to coordinate and regulate the pace of technological growth ensuring broadest possible diffusion and optimum use. Pouring of investment in new technology often unrelated to the growth of real productive capacities leads to speculative bubbles that distort resource allocation. Third, the AI ecosystem is highly energy intensive, and data centres generate huge negative externalities that are often not considered as part of the social cost-benefit analyses in a market economy. Fourth, the current growth of new technology rests on centralisation and concentration of capital at unprecedented levels simply because big tech companies have to establish property rights on data flows that require a monopoly of a global scale as the control on the flow of the key resource, that is data, is not confined to a particular geography as the case may be for minerals or other natural resources.
Most importantly, capitalism faces a contradiction of valorisation as contributions of cognitive labour can hardly be measured by standard notions of labour time. The duration and place of work is increasingly losing importance. This diffusion of space and time also gradually blurs the distinction between work time and non-work time. Also, with knowledge or mental processes assuming a key role in augmenting the use value of a good or service, measuring the individual contribution of the worker in the production process becomes increasingly difficult. Marx in Grundrisse speculated how in advanced phases of capitalism knowledge or the ‘general intellect’ itself becomes a productive power and then production assumes a real social character. Productivity of the individual worker and return based on labour time simply becomes pointless in the new context. In other words, socialisation of production reaches a level when metrics and modes of control based on private property and labour time becomes inconsistent with what the growth of technology and human capacities demand. The existing production relations restrict the growth of productive forces and that creates the context for socialism— a society that embraces social ownership of the means of production. It recognises cooperation in production and operationalises distribution based on the contribution to producing use values. Socialism is the most appropriate system for the growth and development of technologies that thrives on sharing and feedback —as cooperations, and collaborations would not be restricted by myopic profit motives as in capitalism.


